New history teacher Tom Marks arrives in modest Oak Creek, hiding behind antiques and an unaging face. Carrie discovers a basement of haunting relics—dresses and photos of wives who withered while he stayed twenty-eight. Trapped since 1798, Tom’s “living hell” demands a witness to grant him one final, tragic mercy.
Read below or you can listen here.
The morning mist in Oak Creek didn’t so much lift as it did dissolve into the scent of damp pine and woodsmoke. It was a modest town, the kind of place where the loudest sound on a Tuesday morning was the rhythmic thwack of the local newspaper hitting porches and the distant, melodic tolling of the clock tower in the square. Everyone knew everyone’s business, which made the arrival of Tom Marks the most significant event since the old mill closed five years prior.
Tom Marks arrived at Oak Creek High with a quiet gravity that seemed to anchor the frantic energy of the school’s first week. He was the new history teacher, a man characterized by an almost painful modesty and a wardrobe of conservative dress that looked as though it had been pulled from a department store catalog in 1954. While the younger teachers wore corduroy and sneakers, Tom was always in a crisp white shirt, a silk tie of muted burgundy or forest green, and a wool waistcoat that fit him with surgical precision.
Carrie, who had taught English in the room adjacent to his for three years, watched him from the doorway of the faculty lounge. He was leaning over a desk, showing a student a rare pocket watch. The gold of the casing caught the pale autumn sunlight, gleaming with a luster that suggested it was more than just a family heirloom.
“It’s a Lever escapement, 1850s,” Tom was saying, his voice a low, steady baritone that carried an odd, rhythmic cadence. “They don’t make them like this anymore. They don’t make much of anything like this anymore.”
The student, a boy usually more interested in his smartphone than the Industrial Revolution, was leaning in, mesmerized. “Is it worth a lot, Mr. Marks?”
Tom smiled, a gentle expression that didn’t quite reach the shadows in his eyes. “Its value isn’t in gold, son. It’s in the fact that it still keeps perfect time after all the hands that have held it are gone.”
As the student hurried off to class, Carrie stepped into the room, clutching her lukewarm coffee. “You have a way with them, Tom. Most of these kids think history started with the invention of the iPhone.”
“People are simply disconnected from their roots, Carrie,” Tom said, clicking the watch shut with a practiced thumb. He turned to her, offering a polite nod. “They see time as a line moving forward, rather than a cycle we are all trapped within.”
“That’s a bit heavy for 8:15 in the morning,” she joked, though she found herself looking at him more closely. He had a face that was difficult to pin down. His skin was smooth, his jawline firm, yet there was a weariness in his posture that suggested a man who had walked a very long road. He looked to be in his late twenties, perhaps early thirties, yet he carried himself with the heavy dignity of an elder.
Over the next few weeks, Tom Marks became a fixture of Oak Creek. He was popular among staff and students alike, always ready with a kind word or a helping hand with a jammed locker. He was the model citizen, yet he remained deeply private.
The first Friday of the month, the faculty gathered at ‘The Rusty Anchor,’ a small diner that served as the town’s social hub. The air was thick with the smell of fried onions and the boisterous laughter of people who had known each other since kindergarten.
“Come on, Tom,” Sarah, the bubbly gym coach, said, leaning over the vinyl booth. “One beer. It’s the Oak Creek tradition. We have to properly christen the new blood.”
Tom stood at the edge of the group, his overcoat folded neatly over his arm. He gave a small, apologetic bow of his head. “I’m truly honored by the invitation, Sarah. But I’m afraid I have a great deal of grading to finish. Perhaps another time”.
“You said that last week,” Sarah pouted. “And the week before.”
“I am a man of dull habits, I fear,” Tom replied softly. His gaze flickered to the window, where the sun was setting behind the jagged silhouette of the mountains. For a split second, Carrie saw a flash of something in his expression—not boredom, but a profound, aching loneliness.
“He’s a mystery wrapped in a sweater vest,” Sarah whispered to Carrie after Tom had walked out into the cool evening air.
“He’s just private,” Carrie said, though the seed of suspicion had already been planted in her mind.
Oak Creek was the kind of town where privacy was viewed as a challenge. Carrie began to notice small inconsistencies. Tom never spoke of his parents, his childhood, or where he had lived before coming to the valley. When she asked him where he’d done his student teaching, he had given a vague answer about “several institutions out west.”
Her curiosity turned into a quiet obsession. One afternoon, while helping the school secretary, Martha, organize the digitizing of old personnel files, Carrie found the folder for Thomas A. Marks.
“Martha, I think I misfiled Mr. Marks’s background check,” Carrie lied, her heart hammering against her ribs. “Let me just double-check the university seals.”
“Oh, go ahead, honey,” Martha said, distracted by a buzzing telephone.
Carrie opened the folder. What she found didn’t make sense. There were unusual university transcripts from half a dozen prestigious colleges. The dates were modern, yet the courses listed were archaic—advanced studies in Latin, classical Greek, and obscure 19th-century political theory. Some of the degrees seemed to overlap in a way that would have been physically impossible for one person to achieve in a standard lifetime.
Even the paper felt wrong. It was too heavy, too high-quality, as if it were a meticulously crafted imitation of something old.
She felt a chill that had nothing to do with the air conditioning. She remembered Tom’s comment about the watch—after all the hands that held it are gone.
That evening, instead of going home to her quiet apartment, Carrie followed him. She kept her lights off as her car crawled along the gravel road that led away from the modest houses of the town center and up toward the isolated, old house on the hill.
The house was a Victorian relic, its grey paint peeling like dead skin. It sat alone, overlooking the valley, surrounded by overgrown weeds that hissed in the wind. There were no modern amenities visible—no satellite dish, no plastic lawn furniture, no glowing LED porch lights. It was a house that belonged to the past.
Carrie watched from the shadow of a large oak tree as Tom stepped onto the porch. He didn’t check a phone or fumble for a modern key fob. He simply stood for a moment, looking down at the lights of Oak Creek. From this distance, the town looked like a toy set, fragile and temporary.
The wind shifted, carrying the sound of the town’s 9:00 PM whistle. In the silence that followed, Tom pulled out his gold pocket watch. He checked the time, his face illuminated by the pale moon, and for the first time, Carrie realized he wasn’t just a man who liked antiques. He was a man who looked like he was waiting for a century to end.
She drove home in a daze, the quiet streets of Oak Creek suddenly feeling like a stage set. The modesty of the town, the friendliness of the neighbors, the simple rhythm of the school day—it all felt thin, as if Tom Marks was a ghost walking through a world made of paper.
“Who are you, Tom?” she whispered to the empty car.
She didn’t know yet about the lightning strike in 1826, or the fourteen dresses hidden in the basement, or the fact that the man who taught her students history had actually lived it. All she knew was that the new teacher was a man from nowhere, and in a town like Oak Creek, nothing stayed hidden forever. The atmosphere of the town, once cozy and safe, now felt suffocating with the weight of the secret she had stumbled upon. She was no longer just a teacher; she was an investigator, and the man she was investigating was someone who had stopped aging when her own great-grandparents were yet to be born.
The Tuesday morning air in Oak Creek was thick with the scent of damp earth and the charcoal-filtered smell of a dying autumn. It was a town that moved at the speed of a porch swing, where the most pressing gossip usually involved the high school football scores or the price of feed at the co-op. But for Carrie, the quiet was no longer comforting; it felt like a heavy veil draped over something she couldn’t quite see.
She stood in the administrative office of Oak Creek High, her fingers hovering over the drawer labeled M-N. The school was quiet, the students tucked away in second-period classes. Martha, the school secretary, was in the back room, her voice drifting out as she chatted on the phone about a church bake sale.
“I know, I know,” Martha laughed, her voice muffled by the sound of a rustling paper bag. “But Martha’s apple crisp is the only thing that brings in the real donations.”
Carrie took a breath and pulled the drawer open. She shouldn’t be doing this. It was a violation of privacy, a breach of professional ethics. But the “unusual” nature of Tom Marks was a riddle she couldn’t stop trying to solve. She found the folder and pulled it out.
Inside, the unusual university transcripts did not match any standard teaching requirements she had ever seen. There were credits from institutions that had been defunct for decades, and the sheer volume of coursework was staggering—history, philosophy, classical languages, advanced mathematics. It looked like the academic record of three different men merged into one. According to the papers, Tom had more degrees than the rest of the faculty combined, yet he was here, in a modest little town, teaching tenth graders about the Great Depression.
“Carrie? You still looking for that curriculum guide?” Martha asked, stepping back into the main office, wiping her hands on her apron.
Carrie jumped, quickly sliding the folder back into the drawer. “Oh, yes. I think I found what I needed, Martha. Just double-checking some dates for the state board.”
Martha smiled, her eyes crinkling behind her spectacles. “You’re too diligent, dear. A girl your age should be thinking about the Harvest Dance, not state boards. You should ask that handsome Mr. Marks to go. He’s a bit of a hermit, but he’s a polite one.”
“He is polite,” Carrie agreed, her heart still racing. “A bit too polite, maybe.”
Later that afternoon, Carrie watched from her classroom window as Tom walked to his truck. He moved with a steady, unhurried pace, his charcoal-grey overcoat buttoned against the wind. Instead of turning toward the town square, where most of the faculty lived in modest bungalows, Tom headed north, toward the ridge that overlooked the valley.
Driven by a compulsion she couldn’t name, Carrie followed at a distance. She navigated the winding gravel roads that led away from the paved comfort of Oak Creek. The town disappeared behind her, replaced by skeletal trees and the deepening grey of the mountain shadow. Finally, she saw his truck parked at the end of a long, overgrown driveway.
Perched on the crest of the hill was an isolated, old house. It was a Victorian structure that seemed to be bracing itself against the sky, its wood silvered by age and neglect. It looked entirely out of place, a relic of a grander, darker era standing watch over the modest valley below.
She waited until the next day, ensuring Tom was occupied with a late faculty meeting he couldn’t avoid. The guilt of her intrusion was a cold knot in her stomach, but the need for the truth was stronger. She drove back up the hill, parked her car in the brush, and approached the house on foot.
The front door was heavy oak, and to her surprise, it yielded with a soft groan when she turned the handle. She stepped inside and froze. The air didn’t smell like a modern home; it smelled of beeswax, lavender, and the dry, sweet scent of old paper.
The interior was preserved like a time capsule from the 1920s and 30s. There was no television, no computer, no plastic. A heavy gramophone sat in the corner, its brass horn gleaming in the dim light. The furniture was velvet and dark mahogany, arranged with a precision that felt museum-like. Lace doilies sat on the armrests, and a rotary phone—the heavy, black kind that looked like it could survive a war—sat on a side table.
“He lives in a museum,” she whispered, her voice swallowed by the thick rugs.
She moved toward a desk in the study, her eyes landing on a wooden box. When she opened it, she didn’t find jewelry or money. She found photographs. Hundreds of them.
The photos were of women, spanning generations. Some were tintypes from the mid-1800s, others were sepia-toned portraits from the turn of the century, and many were the crisp black-and-white snapshots of the mid-1900s. The women were all beautiful, all smiling, and all posed in front of the same fireplace she saw in the next room.
Her breath hitched as she reached the bottom of the stack. She pulled out a large, hand-tinted photograph in a silver frame. It featured two figures. On the left was a woman who appeared to be well over 100 years old, her face a map of deep wrinkles, her eyes clouded with age but fixed on the camera with a look of fierce devotion.
And standing right beside her, his hand resting gently on her frail shoulder, was Tom Marks.
He looked exactly as he did today. The same modest smile, the same conservative suit, the same timeless eyes. There was no sign of youth in the woman, and no sign of age in the man. The contrast was horrifying.
Carrie dropped the photo, the glass shattering against the hardwood floor. The sound was like a gunshot in the silent house. She realized then that the “unusual transcripts” weren’t a mistake or a forgery. They were the truth. Tom hadn’t just studied history; he had walked through it.
The atmosphere of the house, which had felt like a charming step back in time, suddenly felt suffocating. It wasn’t a home; it was a memorial. A tomb for every woman he had ever known.
She backed away from the desk, her eyes darting to the door. Outside, the wind howled through the eaves of the old house, and the modest town of Oak Creek, with its bake sales and football games, felt like it was a thousand miles away. She had come looking for a secret, but she had found a nightmare—a man who stayed the same while the world, and everyone he loved, crumbled into dust.
She scrambled out of the house, the image of the ancient woman and the young Tom burned into her mind. As she drove back down the hill toward the flickering lights of the town, she knew she couldn’t just keep this to herself. The mystery was gone, replaced by a cold, hard reality that defied every law of nature she knew.
She looked at her own reflection in the rearview mirror—the lines around her eyes, the life she was living in the present. And she thought of Tom, sitting in that house from 1920, waiting for her to come back to class the next morning as if nothing had changed.
The investigation was over, but the discovery had only just begun. And as she reached the paved roads of Oak Creek, she realized that the man she had been trying to understand was someone she should have been running away from all along.
The rain in Oak Creek was not a cleansing downpour; it was a persistent, grey drizzle that turned the town’s modest charm into a landscape of sodden cardboard and slick cobblestones. The smell of wet asphalt and dying marigolds hung heavy in the air as Carrie walked toward the high school, her hand trembling slightly around the handle of a manila folder. In a town where the most scandalous news was usually a broken window at the hardware store, the secret she carried felt like a physical weight, pressing against her ribs.
Inside Oak Creek High, the afternoon was winding down. The lockers were mostly empty, the echoed shouts of students fading as they ran for the buses to escape the damp chill. Carrie stood outside Tom’s classroom, her heart hammering a frantic rhythm against her chest. Through the small window in the door, she saw him. He was at his desk, the yellow glow of a single lamp illuminating his profile. He was meticulously cleaning his rare pocket watch with a soft cloth, his movements as steady and deliberate as a ticking clock. He looked exactly like the man who had arrived only weeks ago—modest, conservatively dressed, and utterly out of place.
She pushed the door open. The hinge gave a familiar, mournful squeak. Tom didn’t look up immediately.
“The students are gone, Carrie,” he said, his voice a calm, rich baritone. “You shouldn’t stay late on a day like this. The roads toward the ridge get treacherous in the rain.”
“I wasn’t worried about the roads, Tom,” Carrie said, her voice sounding thin and brittle to her own ears. She stepped forward and placed the folder on his desk, right next to the gleaming gold watch. “I was worried about this.”
Tom paused, the cloth poised over the gold casing. He looked at the folder, then slowly looked up at her. His eyes were unreadable—deep, dark pools that seemed to contain more years than his young face could possibly justify. He opened the folder.
On top was the photograph she had taken from his house. It showed Tom alongside a woman who appeared to be over 100 years old. Her hand was a claw of wrinkled skin resting on his arm, her eyes full of a terrifying, ancient devotion. Beside her, Tom looked twenty-eight, his face unlined, his smile frozen in a youth that the woman beside him had long since lost.
The silence in the room became absolute. Outside, the rhythmic thwack-thwack of a windshield wiper from a passing car was the only sign that the world was still moving.
“Where did you get this?” Tom asked. There was no anger in his voice, only a profound, hollow exhaustion.
“I went to your house, Tom. The isolated house on the hill,” Carrie whispered, her breath hitching. “I saw how you live. I saw the transcripts in your file at the office—the ones that don’t make any sense. I saw this photo. Who is she? How can you be there, looking exactly like you do now, while she’s… like that?”
Tom didn’t answer. He didn’t offer a lie about a grandfather or a great-uncle who happened to look like him. He simply stared at the image, his thumb tracing the edge of the woman’s withered face.
“Her name was Sarah,” he said softly, almost to himself. “She was the last one who remembered the sound of my real name.”
“Tom, talk to me,” Carrie pleaded, stepping closer. “What is this? Are you in some kind of trouble? Is this some kind of… trick?”
Tom stood up abruptly. The chair scraped harshly against the linoleum floor. He reached into his desk, pulled out a single sheet of school stationery, and began to write. He didn’t look at her as he moved. His handwriting was elegant, an archaic script that belonged to the 19th century rather than the 21st.
“I think it’s best if I leave,” he said, his voice flat.
“Leave? Tom, you can’t just leave! You have classes, you have a life here—”
“I have no life here, Carrie. I have only a tenure,” he interrupted. He slid the paper across the desk. It was a formal letter of resignation, effective immediately.
“You’re not even going to explain?” Carrie asked, her eyes stinging with tears of frustration and fear. “You’re just going to disappear like a ghost?”
Tom abruptly resigned without another word. He grabbed his charcoal overcoat, snapped his pocket watch shut, and walked past her. He didn’t look back. By the time Carrie reached the hallway, he was gone, his silhouette swallowed by the grey mist of the parking lot. He had disappeared from the school as if he had never been part of it at all.
The rest of the evening felt like a fever dream. Carrie drove through the quiet streets of Oak Creek, past the general store and the small park where the town’s veterans’ memorial stood. Everything looked smaller, more fragile. She found herself driving back toward the ridge, toward the isolated, old house. She knew he wouldn’t be there—his truck was gone from the school—but she couldn’t stay away.
The house sat like a silent sentinel on the hill, overlooking the valley. The rain had turned to a light fog that clung to the Victorian gables. Carrie let herself back in, the air inside still smelling of beeswax and 1920s nostalgia.
She returned to the study, her hands shaking as she searched for the wooden box she had seen before. She found it tucked away in a bottom drawer. When she opened it this time, she didn’t just look at the top photo. She emptied the contents onto the floor.
It was a cascade of history. There were daguerreotypes from the 1840s, tintypes from the Civil War era, and glossy prints from the 1950s. And in every single one of them, there was Tom. He stood in front of log cabins, Victorian mansions, and mid-century bungalows. He wore Union blue, then pinstriped suits, then the modest wool he wore today. Tom was present in every single photo, always the same age, always twenty-eight, while the women beside him changed, aged, and eventually disappeared from the record.
“It’s not a trick,” she whispered, the cold of the house finally seeping into her bones.
She picked up a photo from what looked like the 1940s. Tom was standing in a garden with a woman in a floral dress. They looked happy. But in the next photo in the stack, the same woman was grey-haired and stooped, while Tom remained a frozen monument of youth.
The realization hit her like a physical blow. He wasn’t a man with a secret; he was a man who was a secret. He was a living history, a man born in 1798 who had stopped aging because of a lightning strike in 1826. He had watched his parents and his bride die, and then he had spent nearly two centuries watching the world grow old without him.
As she sat on the floor, surrounded by the ghosts of Tom’s past, the front door creaked open. The wind didn’t howl; it just sighed.
“I wondered if you’d come back,” a voice said from the shadows of the hallway.
Carrie looked up. Tom was standing in the doorway, his coat wet from the rain. He didn’t look like a monster, and he didn’t look like a hero. He just looked like a man who had seen too many sunsets.
“You’re present in every single photo,” she said, her voice trembling as she held up a handful of the pictures.
“Yes,” Tom said, stepping into the light of the study. “And that is why I have to leave. Because eventually, Carrie, you would be in one of those photos too. And you would get old, and you would die, and I would still be standing here, holding a watch that never stops, in a world that never waits.”
The atmosphere in the room shifted. The “modest” teacher was gone, replaced by the burden of immortality. The silence of the town below felt like a mockery of the eternal silence Tom carried within him. He had over 20 academic degrees and a lifetime of knowledge, but as he looked at Carrie, all he seemed to have was the exhaustion of a man who was desperate for a rest that would never come.
“I was born in 1798,” he said, the words falling like stones into a well. “And I have been resigning from lives ever since.”
Carrie looked at the photos scattered around her, then back at the man who had survived two world wars and a dozen lifetimes. She realized that his resignation wasn’t just from the school; it was his way of surviving the horror of his own existence. But as she saw the way his hand gripped the doorframe, she knew that this time, the resignation wasn’t going to be enough to let him disappear. The secret was out, and in the quiet, modest hills of Oak Creek, the past had finally caught up with the man who could never leave it behind.
The wind outside the Victorian gables of the ridge house didn’t howl; it whispered, a low, mourning sound that seemed to carry the collective sighs of Oak Creek below. In the valley, the modest town was a patchwork of amber porch lights and the faint, rhythmic pulse of the clock tower, but up here, time felt as though it had curdled. Carrie stood in the center of the study, the floorboards beneath her feet groaning under the weight of the scattered photographs—a hundred years of women, all dead or dying, while the man who had loved them stood in the doorway, frozen in a perpetual twenty-eighth year.
Tom didn’t move. The rain-dampened wool of his overcoat gave off the scent of wet sheep and ozone. He looked at the photo in Carrie’s hand—the one of him standing beside the woman who looked a century old—and for a moment, the polite mask of the popular high school teacher didn’t just slip; it shattered.
“You should have stayed in the town, Carrie,” he said, his voice no longer the warm baritone of the faculty lounge. It was hollow, like wind blowing through an empty cathedral. “Oak Creek is a place for people who live in seasons. I don’t belong in seasons.”
“Who is she, Tom?” Carrie’s voice trembled as she held up the photo of the ancient woman. “And how are you… this? You haven’t aged a day since this was taken. You haven’t aged a day since you arrived here.”
Tom stepped into the room, the yellow light of the desk lamp casting a long, jagged shadow against the 1920s wallpaper. He reached out and took the photo from her. His fingers were steady, unlined, and terrifyingly young.
“I was born in 1798,” he said, the words falling with the finality of a gavel.
Carrie let out a breath she hadn’t realized she was holding, a sharp, disbelieving laugh. “That’s impossible. That would make you… over two hundred years old.”
“Two hundred and twenty-eight, to be precise,” Tom replied, his gaze fixed on the woman in the photo. “That was Sarah. She was my third wife. She died in 1924. I stayed with her until the very end, watching her skin turn to parchment and her memory fail, while I remained the same man who had married her forty years earlier.”
He walked to the window, looking down at the flickering lights of Oak Creek. From this height, the modest town looked like a toy set, a temporary thing built of matchsticks and paper.
“It happened in 1826,” he continued, his voice drifting back into the past. “I was twenty-eight years old. I had a life then—a real life. I had parents who loved me and a bride named Amanda. We were caught in a storm on our way home from the chapel. A summer storm, the kind that turns the sky the color of a bruise. A bolt of lightning struck the carriage.”
He closed his eyes, and Carrie could almost see the reflection of that ancient flash in his pupils.
“It killed my parents and my bride instantly,” he whispered. “The doctors said it was a miracle I survived. They didn’t realize the miracle was a curse. I woke up three days later, and the world had started to move on, but I had stopped. I waited for the grey to come to my hair. I waited for the lines to etch themselves into my face. But the years passed, and I remained a monument to that single, electrified second.”
Carrie sat heavily in a velvet armchair, the air in the room feeling thick and ancient. “So you just… stayed twenty-eight?”
“I have lived a life of eternal youth, Carrie, and it is a burden heavier than any casket,” Tom said, turning back to her. “I have served in both World Wars. I have seen the cavalry replaced by tanks and the telegraph replaced by the glowing screens your students carry in their pockets. I have watched empires fall and the very air of this planet change. And through it all, I have had to hide.”
He gestured to the desk, where his unusual university transcripts lay. “I have over 20 academic degrees,” he explained with a weary smile. “Whenever people start to notice—whenever the neighbors in a town like Oak Creek start to wonder why the history teacher doesn’t seem to age—I move. I change my name, I change my credentials, and I start again. Education is the easiest way to blend in; a perpetual student or a new teacher is never questioned too closely.”
“But the women, Tom,” Carrie said, gesturing to the box of photos. “The wives.”
Tom’s expression darkened with a profound, aching grief. “That is the cruelest part of the ‘living hell’. I tried to live alone. I tried to be a hermit. But the loneliness is a hunger that never ends. So, I would fall in love. I would marry. And every single time, I had to watch the numerous wives age and die while I remained unchanged. I have buried fourteen women, Carrie. Fourteen lives that I shared, only to become a stranger to them as they grew old and I did not.”
The atmosphere of the modest town below, with its simple cycles of birth and death, felt like a paradise Tom could see but never enter. In Oak Creek, people worried about the winter frost killing their gardens or their children moving away after graduation. They lived in a world where time was a gift because it was limited. For Tom, time was a vast, featureless ocean.
“I came here because Oak Creek felt like a place where time had slowed down,” Tom said, his voice dropping to a whisper. “I thought I could disappear here for a few years. Be the ‘mysterious new teacher’ with the old watch and the quiet life. But you were too smart, Carrie. You looked too close.”
Carrie looked at him, really looked at him, and saw the truth of his burden. He wasn’t a man blessed with immortality; he was a man trapped in a prison of his own cells. Every degree he earned, every move he made, every wife he buried was another brick in the wall of his isolation.
“Why tell me this now?” she asked.
Tom reached into his vest and pulled out the rare pocket watch, clicking it open. The gold surface reflected the dim light of the study, a relic of the mid-19th century that, like its owner, refused to stop ticking.
“Because I am tired, Carrie,” he said, and for the first time, she saw the true depth of his exhaustion. “The world is getting too small. There are too many cameras, too many databases, too many people like you who notice the inconsistencies. My secret is becoming a weight I can no longer carry alone.”
He looked out the window one last time at the modest lights of the town. “I’ve spent two centuries running from the grave. But tonight, standing here in this house that is nothing but a museum of my own failures, I realized that I don’t want to run anymore.”
The silence that followed was heavy with the weight of two hundred years. Carrie looked at the man from 1798, a man who had seen the birth of a nation and the death of everyone he had ever loved, and she realized that the popular teacher she had suspected of being a fraud was something far more tragic. He was a man who had been given forever and wanted nothing more than a single, quiet end.
The rain that had plagued Oak Creek during Tom’s resignation had settled into a thick, cloying fog by the following evening. In the town below, the modest rhythm of life continued—the neon sign of the diner flickered, the high school football team’s practice whistles echoed faintly, and the residents discussed the “mysterious Mr. Marks” over fences and dinner tables. To them, he was just a talented teacher who had moved on too soon. To Carrie, he was a ghost who had left her haunted.
Driven by a gnawing guilt and a desperate need to find some piece of evidence that would make the impossible story he told her feel like something other than a hallucination, she drove back to the isolated house on the hill. Tom had told her he was heading for the West Coast, intending to start another cycle of his “living hell” in a place where no one knew his face. The house should have been empty, a hollow shell of 19th-century memories.
She let herself in, the heavy oak door swinging open on silent hinges. The house was cold, the smell of beeswax now overshadowed by the dampness of the fog. She moved through the parlor, her flashlight beam dancing over the velvet furniture and the gramophone. But her curiosity—or perhaps a subconscious warning—drew her toward the back of the house, toward a door she had previously ignored: the entrance to the basement.
As she pulled the door open, a wave of cold, stagnant air hit her. It didn’t smell like a typical cellar. It didn’t smell of coal dust or laundry. It smelled of death—a sweet, sickly rot that made her stomach churn and her skin crawl.
“It’s just an old house,” she whispered to the shadows, her voice trembling. “Damp rot and dead mice.”
She descended the wooden stairs, each step a sharp crack in the silence. The basement was larger than the house above suggested, divided into several stone-walled chambers. In the center of the main room stood a long wooden rack. Her flashlight beam hit the fabric first—satin, wool, lace, and silk. She walked closer, her breath hitching in her throat.
Hanging there, perfectly preserved but chillingly empty, were 14 period dresses. There was a heavy wool traveling gown from the mid-1800s, a beaded flapper dress from the 1920s, a floral housecoat from the 40s, and a sleek, modest evening gown that looked like it belonged in a 1960s ballroom. They were arranged in a line, like a timeline of fashion—or a collection of trophies.
Beside the rack, on a small stone pedestal, sat a leather-bound photo album. Carrie reached for it with numb fingers. This wasn’t the box of loose photos she had found upstairs; this was something more organized, more deliberate. She opened the first page.
It was a “before and after” display. On the left side of the first page was a beautiful, young woman in a high-collared Victorian dress, her eyes bright with life. On the right was the same woman, but her face was a mask of skeletal decay, her eyes sunken, her skin gray. The “after” photo hadn’t been taken during her life; it was a post-mortem portrait, a common but macabre practice of the 19th century.
She flipped the page. Another woman, vibrant and smiling in a 1920s sun hat. On the right, the same woman in a casket, her features distorted by the very age Tom claimed he didn’t share. Page after page, the pattern repeated: fourteen women, fourteen “before” shots of youth and love, and fourteen “after” shots of cold, lifeless husks.
The “burden of immortality” Tom had described suddenly felt like a carefully constructed lie. The smell of death in the basement wasn’t just old air; it was the scent of a predator’s den.
“He didn’t watch them age,” Carrie whispered, her heart thundering against her ribs. “He watched them die. He made them die.”
The realization hit her with the force of a physical blow: Tom was actually a serial killer. The story of the lightning strike, the 1798 birth, the eternal youth—it was the elaborate mythology of a madman who used the isolation of small towns like Oak Creek to harvest his victims. And now, she realized with a jolt of pure terror, she was the only one who had ever looked behind the curtain.
She dropped the album, the sound of leather hitting stone echoing like a thunderclap. She turned to run, her flashlight beam swinging wildly across the stone walls. She scrambled up the basement stairs, her boots slipping on the wood. She reached the kitchen, her eyes fixed on the back door. She just had to get to her car, get to the sheriff, get away from this hill.
She threw the door open, but she didn’t find the foggy night air. She found a solid, unyielding wall of charcoal-grey wool.
Tom Marks was standing on the threshold. He wasn’t wearing his polite, teacherly smile. His face was a mask of cold, terrifying stillness. In his hand, he held a heavy, dark-steeled revolver.
“I told you that the roads were treacherous, Carrie,” he said, his voice low and devoid of emotion. “I told you that you shouldn’t have come back.”
“Tom, please,” Carrie gasped, backing away, her hands raised in a useless gesture of defense. “I… I was just leaving. I won’t say anything. I’ll leave Oak Creek. I’ll never mention your name.”
“You saw the basement,” Tom said, stepping into the kitchen and closing the door behind him. The click of the lock was final. “You saw the dresses. You saw the album.”
“I know what you are,” she hissed, her fear turning into a desperate, cornered anger. “You’re not a miracle. You’re a monster. You’ve been killing them for two hundred years.”
Tom looked at her, and for a second, a flicker of that profound, ancient exhaustion crossed his features, but it was quickly replaced by a hard, metallic resolve. He raised the gun, the barrel pointing directly at her chest.
“You don’t understand the first thing about what I am,” he said. “But you’re right about one thing. This cycle has to end.”
He prevented Carrie from leaving and, with a jerk of the weapon, forced her at gunpoint back into the main part of the house. The atmosphere of the modest town below, where neighbors were currently settling in for a quiet night, felt like a distant, unreachable dream. In the “time capsule” house, the air was thick with the scent of the basement and the looming threat of the “final dinner” Tom had prepared for his next intended victim.
“Move,” he commanded, his voice as cold as the stone walls of the basement. “We have a long evening ahead of us, and I want everything to be perfect. After all, it’s been a very long time since I’ve had a guest who knew the truth.”
The fog that had swallowed Oak Creek seemed to thicken as it climbed the ridge, turning the Victorian house into a ghost ship adrift in a white sea. Inside, the terror of the basement still clung to Carrie like the scent of woodsmoke—the memory of those 14 period dresses and the “after” photos of the women who had once worn them. She looked at the man standing before her, the teacher who had arrived with a quiet smile and a rare pocket watch, and saw only a monster.
“Go upstairs, Carrie,” Tom said, his voice as steady as the ticking of the clock in the hall. The revolver in his hand didn’t waver. “In the master bedroom, you will find a gown laid out on the bed. Put it on.”
“Tom, please,” Carrie whispered, her voice cracking. “Don’t do this. Whatever you think I am, whatever you think I’ve seen… I just want to go home.”
“You are going to dinner,” Tom replied, a strange, hollow courtesy in his tone that was more unsettling than a shout. “It’s been a very long time since I’ve had a guest for a proper final meal. You will dress, and you will join me in the pergola. Do not make me come and find you.”
Driven by the cold metallic promise of the gun, Carrie climbed the stairs. In the bedroom, she found a gown of midnight-blue silk, its style a perfect recreation of the late 1930s. It was elegant, timeless, and felt like a shroud. As she pulled it on, the silk cold against her skin, she looked out the window. Down in the valley, Oak Creek was a scattering of dim ambers and soft whites. The modest little town was settling in for the night; the 10:00 PM whistle had just blown, a sound that usually meant safety and the end of a long day. From here, the lives of her neighbors seemed like a beautiful, fragile dream that she was no longer allowed to share.
She descended the stairs, the silk rustling like dry leaves. Tom was waiting in the foyer, now dressed in a full tuxedo that looked as if it had been tailored a century ago. He didn’t look at her with lust or the hunger of a killer; he looked at her with the clinical appreciation of a curator.
“You look like a memory,” he said softly.
He led her out the back door, through a garden overgrown with weeds that shimmered with frost, to a white wooden pergola that sat on the very edge of the ridge. It was illuminated by dozens of flickering candles in glass hurricanes. A table was set with fine china, heavy silver, and a bottle of wine that had likely been aging since before Carrie was born.
“Sit,” Tom commanded, gesturing to a chair. He placed the revolver on the table between them, its dark steel a jarring contrast to the delicate lace of the tablecloth.
For a long time, the only sound was the clink of silverware and the distant, lonely howl of a dog in the valley below. Tom ate with a slow, practiced grace, his eyes fixed on the lights of Oak Creek.
“They think they have forever,” Tom said finally, gesturing toward the town. “The people down there. They worry about their mortgages, their high school rivals, the gossip at the diner. They think their lives are a long, unfolding story. They don’t realize that in the blink of an eye, the story ends. And for them, that is a mercy.”
“A mercy?” Carrie asked, her hands trembling as she held a glass of wine she couldn’t bring herself to drink. “How can you call death a mercy after what I saw in that basement? Those photos… those women… you killed them, Tom. You kept their dresses like trophies.”
Tom looked at her, and for the first time, the coldness in his eyes broke, replaced by a surge of raw, ancient pain. “I didn’t kill them, Carrie. Time killed them. I merely watched.”
He leaned forward, the candlelight carving deep shadows into his unlined face. “I am exhausted by this immortal ‘living hell’,” he confessed, his voice a ragged whisper. “You saw the ‘after’ photos. You saw what happens when a man stays twenty-eight while the woman he loves turns to dust before his eyes. I watched Sarah go from a girl who loved the spring to a woman who couldn’t remember her own name. I watched Amanda die in the storm that gave me this curse. I have watched fourteen lives burn out like candles, while I remain the flame that cannot be extinguished.”
“If you loved them, why the basement? Why the dresses?”
“Because I couldn’t let them go!” Tom shouted, the sudden volume making Carrie flinch. He slumped back, his shoulders sagging under the weight of two centuries. “They were my anchors. Every dress, every photo, was a way to remind myself that I was once part of the world. But now… now I am just a ghost that refuses to vanish. I have lost everyone I have ever loved, and the pain of it isn’t something that fades with time, Carrie. It compounds. It grows until every breath feels like a betrayal of the dead.”
He looked down at the town again. “I tried to find peace in Oak Creek. I thought a modest life in a modest town would be enough to quiet the noise of the years. But the silence here only makes the ticking of that watch louder.”
He reached out and picked up the revolver. Carrie squeezed her eyes shut, waiting for the end. Instead, she heard a heavy thud. She opened her eyes to see the gun lying on the grass outside the pergola.
“It’s unloaded,” Tom said, his voice devoid of all strength. He reached into his pocket and pulled out a set of keys, sliding them across the table toward her. “Those are the keys to my truck. You are free to leave, Carrie. Go back to your modest town. Go back to your life that ends. Go back to the mercy of growing old”.
Carrie stared at the keys, then at the man across from her. The “serial killer” she had feared was gone. In his place was a man who was desperate for rest, a man whose immortality was not a gift of the gods, but the ultimate isolation. The atmosphere of the dinner, which had begun as a nightmare, had shifted into a wake.
“Why didn’t you just tell me?” she asked softly.
“Who would believe a man who says he was born in 1798?” Tom replied with a bitter smile. “Even you, who saw the evidence, chose to believe I was a murderer rather than believe the truth. The truth is too heavy for the living.”
Carrie looked at the truck keys, but she didn’t pick them up. She looked at Tom, seeing the way his hands shook as he gripped the edge of the table. She thought of the 14 dresses and the empty pages at the end of the photo album. She realized then that Tom hadn’t brought her here to kill her. He had brought her here because he couldn’t bear to be alone for the end of his story.
The fog began to drift into the pergola, swirling around the candles. Below, the final lights of Oak Creek were winking out as the town went to sleep. But up on the ridge, the man who had seen the world change for two hundred years was finally looking at the one thing he had been denied for so long.
“I can’t do it myself, Carrie,” Tom whispered, his eyes pleading. “I’ve tried. The lightning changed something. The world won’t let me go. I’ve lived through wars and plagues and my own hand, and I always wake up at twenty-eight.”
The silence of the night settled over them, a heavy, velvet curtain. Carrie realized that the final formal dinner wasn’t a celebration of life, but a final request for a mercy that only a friend—or a witness—could provide. The “living hell” he had described was etched into every line of his posture, and as the candles began to gutter out, Carrie felt the weight of the manila folder and the “after” photos being replaced by a much darker, much more profound responsibility.
“I’m so tired,” Tom said, his head bowing. “Please. I just want to sleep.”
The fog that had blanketed Oak Creek for hours finally began to thin, shredded by a cold wind that swept down from the mountains. Below the ridge, the modest town was a grid of silent streets and dark windows. The 11:00 PM freight train rumbled through the valley, its mournful whistle a reminder of a world that kept moving, kept changing, and eventually, kept leaving things behind. But on the hill, in the shadow of the Victorian house, time felt like it had finally reached a standstill.
Carrie stood in the white wooden pergola, the silk of the midnight-blue gown rustling against her legs. The keys to Tom’s truck lay on the table between them, a silver promise of escape. Tom sat across from her, his tuxedo jacket discarded, his white shirt glowing like a shroud in the candlelight. The revolver—the one he had claimed was unloaded—lay in the grass where he had tossed it.
“Go, Carrie,” Tom said, his voice barely a whisper. “Drive down to the town. Find a life that has an ending. Marry a man who will grow grey with you. It is the greatest gift a human can have, and I have spent two centuries envying it.”
Carrie looked at the keys, then back at Tom. The fear that had gripped her in the basement—the belief that he was a serial killer—had evaporated, replaced by a crushing, leaden weight of empathy. She saw now that the 14 period dresses weren’t trophies of murder; they were the only things he had left of the women he had loved and lost to the inevitable march of years. He wasn’t a predator; he was a man desperate for rest.
“You said you’ve tried to end it yourself,” Carrie said, her voice steadying. “Why can’t you?”
Tom looked up, his eyes reflecting the guttering candle flames. “I told you, the lightning in 1826 changed the very fabric of what I am. I have walked into fires, I have stood before firing squads in the Great War, and I have felt the cold of the Atlantic. Every time, I wake up. Every time, I am twenty-eight, and the world is still there, mocking me with its permanence.”
He stood up and walked to the edge of the pergola, looking toward a dark patch of woods behind the house. “I realized long ago that I cannot break the cycle from the inside. I need a witness. I need someone who exists in time to pull me out of it.”
Carrie felt a cold shiver that had nothing to do with the night air. “You want me to do it.”
“I have previously dug a grave for myself,” Tom said, turning to face her. “It’s been waiting for years. I thought I could find the courage to lie in it and wait for the earth to take me, but the earth won’t take what won’t die. It needs a push, Carrie. It needs a final mercy.”
For a moment, the atmosphere of Oak Creek seemed to press in on them—the modesty of the town, its simple births, its quiet funerals in the churchyard. It was a place where death was handled with dignity and flowers. What Tom was asking for was something else entirely.
“Show me,” Carrie whispered.
She followed him out of the light of the pergola and into the deep shadows of the woods. The ground was slick with wet leaves and pine needles. They walked in silence until they reached a small clearing where the moonlight broke through the canopy. There, a rectangular mound of fresh earth sat beside a deep, dark trench. It was a perfect, professional grave, dug with the same meticulous care Tom applied to his teaching and his antiques.
Tom stood at the edge of the pit. He looked at the moon, his face filled with a longing so profound it made Carrie’s heart ache.
“I am so tired of remembering,” he said. “I am tired of the degrees, the names, the cities, and the faces that fade. I just want the silence.”
He reached into his pocket and pulled out a handful of brass casings. He walked back to where he had tossed the gun, picked it up, and loaded it with steady hands. He held the weapon out to her, handle-first.
“Following my request,” he said, his voice thick with emotion. “Help me find peace.”
Carrie took the gun. It was heavy and cold, a piece of modern machinery designed for the very thing Tom craved. She looked at him—the man who had been born in 1798, who had seen the world change from horse-drawn carriages to satellites, and who was now asking a history teacher from a small town to end his long, lonely story.
“Close your eyes, Tom,” she whispered.
He did, a small, peaceful smile touching his lips. Carrie raised the revolver. The silence of the woods was absolute. Not even the wind dared to move. She thought of the photo album in the basement, the “before” photos of the women who had loved him, and the “after” photos of the rest he had finally provided for them.
She pulled the trigger.
The sound was a cannon blast in the quiet night. Carrie shot him multiple times, the flashes of the muzzle illuminating the woods in jagged bursts of light. With each impact, Tom’s body recoiled until, finally, he fell into the grave he had prepared.
Carrie stood over the edge for a long time, the smoke from the gun curling into the moonlight. There was no movement from the pit. For the first time in two hundred years, Tom Marks was still.
She didn’t leave. She couldn’t. She walked back to the house, her blue silk gown trailing through the mud. She went into the basement, where the 14 period dresses hung like colorful ghosts. One by one, she gathered them—the Victorian wool, the 1920s silk, the 1940s floral. She carried them out to the woods and laid them over him, covering the man from nowhere with the only remnants of the lives he had shared.
Next, she retrieved the leather-bound photo album. She flipped to the very last page, which had remained blank. She reached into her own pocket and pulled out a small polaroid she had taken during the school’s autumn festival—a picture of her laughing in front of the history wing. She tucked it into the sleeve, adding her own photo to the final blank page, ensuring she was the last face he would ever be associated with. She placed the album on top of the dresses.
Then, she began the long, grueling work of the burial. She used the shovel he had left behind, moving the earth back into the trench. As she worked, the sun began to peek over the horizon, casting a pale, cold light over Oak Creek. The town was waking up. She could hear the distant sound of a tractor and the first birds of the morning. To the people down there, this would be just another day. They would go to school, they would ask where the popular Mr. Marks had gone, and they would eventually move on.
When the grave was level with the forest floor, Carrie covered it with leaves and branches until it was invisible. She was exhausted, her hands blistered and her gown ruined, but she felt a strange, hollow peace.
She walked back to the truck and climbed inside. On the dashboard, she found a small, folded piece of school stationery. She opened it with trembling fingers. It wasn’t a long explanation or a list of degrees. It was a final note in that elegant, 19th-century script.
It simply said: “Thank you”.
Carrie started the engine and drove down the hill. As she reached the paved streets of Oak Creek, she saw the modest houses, the well-kept lawns, and the local diner beginning to puff smoke from its chimney. It was a town that lived in the present, a town that accepted the cycle of the seasons.
She looked in the rearview mirror at the ridge, where the isolated house sat silent and empty. The mystery of the new teacher was over. The man who had been born before the town was even a name on a map was finally part of the earth beneath it. Carrie drove through the square, past the clock tower that marked the passing minutes, and headed home, carrying the secret of a final mercy that the world would never know.
Reid Carsen 
Leave a comment